Get the book

Questions

Win It ยท Kitchen Table

Should we make an offer before the auction?

The short answer

It depends on whether you would be happy to be bound by it. In Victoria, a pre-auction offer accepted less than three clear business days before the auction has no cooling-off, the same as a winning bid. Settle at home whether you would offer early, and the last day you would say yes.

The moment

The agent rings on a Thursday night. The seller might take an offer before Saturday. The place could be yours by Friday, with no crowd, no bidding and no auctioneer. Saying yes can feel like the calm choice, and the call can feel like a private sale.

The calendar says otherwise.

The rule behind it

In a private sale in Victoria, a buyer usually has three clear business days to cool off, counted from the day the buyer signs. Consumer Affairs Victoria lists the cases where there is none. Three of them sit around an auction:

When the contract is made Cooling-off?
Bought at a public auction No
Signed within three clear business days before or after a public auction No
A pre-auction offer accepted less than three clear business days before the auction No

So an offer accepted late in auction week leaves you, as the hammer would, with no cooling-off to fall back on. Unlike the auction, it is negotiated like a private sale, so a condition such as finance is in it only if you asked for it and the seller agreed. At the auction itself, Consumer Affairs Victoria says you cannot add conditions, such as finance, unless the seller agrees. Ask what the agent's contract says before you offer.

Count the days

An example, not your dates. The auction is on a Saturday. Take a calendar and cross out the weekend and any public holiday. The pages do not explain how clear business days are counted, so this is one common way to read it, not the page's: leave out the day the offer is accepted and the auction day, and count the business days in between.

An offer accepted on the Wednesday leaves two, the Thursday and the Friday. One accepted on the Thursday leaves one. Both are fewer than three, so there is no cooling-off, and the same goes for the Friday. If it is the Tuesday or earlier, or the week has a public holiday in it, ask your conveyancer to do the count for your contract. The count is easy to get wrong by one day.

Mark one day on that calendar: the last day you would say yes to an early offer. Write your price beside it.

Your table tonight

  1. Would we offer before the auction at all, or wait for the day?
  2. What is the last day we would say yes, counting back from the auction?
  3. Is our finance far enough along to be bound that day?
  4. Has our conveyancer read the contract and the Section 32 yet?
  5. What price would we offer, and is it the same number we would stop bidding at?
Decide first, at home

An early offer moves the deciding forward by days. Answer the five questions above before the agent rings, so the call is a yes or a no you have already made.

Who to ask

Your conveyancer, to count the days for your contract and read it before you offer. Your lender, to say how far your loan approval has to be before you are bound. We can't tell you whether to offer, or what to offer.

The official pages

Related: Is there a cooling-off period at auction in Victoria?

How this answer was written

Written by the First Home with Grace team with AI help, from the official pages listed above. Every fact was checked against its page on the date shown. Rules change, so check the official page on the day.

This is step 8 of the book

Step 8 of Calm Steps to Your First Home is "Auction or private sale". It ends with the Bidding Limit Sheet, a tool you fill in at home.